Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links marked with (Ad). If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more

Shelter Island, New York

Last updated: 2024 BLS data · Page refreshed:

City Profile — Demographics, Income, Education & Housing
Data: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2024 5-Year Estimates
2,125
Population
$165,734
Median Income
$1,025,400
Home Value
41.3
Median Age

Demographics

Shelter Island has a population of 2,125 with a median age of 41.3. Here is the racial and ethnic breakdown of the population:

White
57.0%
Hispanic
31.8%
Other
11.2%
Demographic Value
Total Population2,125
Median Age41.3
White57.0%
Hispanic or Latino31.8%
Other / Two or More Races11.2%
Shelter Island, New York — racial composition (Census ACS 2024)Donut chart of 3 segments totaling 100.White: 57.0%Hispanic/Latino: 31.8%Other: 11.2%2,125PopulationWhiteWhite57.0%Hispanic/LatinoHispanic/Latino31.8%OtherOther11.2%

Income & Economy

The median household income in Shelter Island is $165,734, which is 105.6% above the national median of $80,610. The per capita income is $58,080. The poverty rate is 0.9%.

$165,734
Median Household Income
$58,080
Per Capita Income
0.9%
Poverty Rate

Advance Your Career in Shelter Island

Tools that help you land a better-paying role — wherever you live. · Sponsored - see disclosure.

MyPerfectResume · (Ad)
Create an ATS-friendly resume in minutes. Trusted by millions of job seekers.
Build My Resume →
FlexJobs · (Ad)
Access 50,000+ vetted remote, hybrid, and flexible job listings. No ads, no scams.
Find Remote & Flexible Jobs →
ExpertRating · (Ad)
300+ online certifications in Project Management, Six Sigma, IT & more.
Get Certified & Earn More →
Mondly by Pearson · (Ad)
Join 140M+ learners. Master any of 41 languages with bite-sized lessons.
Learn a New Language →

Education

In Shelter Island, 85.4% of residents age 25+ have a high school diploma or higher, and 56.0% hold a bachelor's degree or higher (25.8% with a graduate or professional degree).

HS Diploma+
85.4%
Bachelor's+
56.0%
Graduate+
25.8%
Education Level % of Adults (25+)
High School Diploma or Higher85.4%
Bachelor's Degree or Higher56.0%
Graduate or Professional Degree25.8%

Housing

The median home value in Shelter Island is $1,025,400, above the national median of $303,400. The homeownership rate is 89.3%.

$1,025,400
Median Home Value
89.3%
Homeownership Rate
Housing Metric Value
Median Home Value$1,025,400
Homeownership Rate89.3%
Vacancy Rate51.6%

Salaries in New York

Explore salary data for popular occupations in New York:

See all New York salaries →

Other Cities in New York

See all New York cities →

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the population of Shelter Island, New York?
The population of Shelter Island, New York is 2,125 according to U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2024 5-Year Estimates.
What is the median household income in Shelter Island, New York?
The median household income in Shelter Island, New York is $165,734. This is 105.6% above the national median of $80,610.
What is the median home value in Shelter Island, New York?
The median home value in Shelter Island, New York is $1,025,400.
What percentage of people in Shelter Island have a college degree?
In Shelter Island, New York, 56.0% of adults age 25 and older hold a bachelor's degree or higher, and 85.4% have a high school diploma or higher.
Is Shelter Island, New York an affordable place to live?
The home price-to-income ratio in Shelter Island, New York is 6.2x (median home value $1,025,400 vs. median income $165,734), making it relatively expensive by that measure. A ratio under 4.0 is generally considered affordable.

🏠 Thinking About Moving to Shelter Island?

Find resources to help plan your move, explore homes, and compare insurance rates in New York.

Salary Data in New York

All Jobs in New York Highest Paying Jobs Jobs Over $100K Average Salary

🏘️ Get City & Demographic Insights

Free data-driven updates on cities, salaries & cost of living — no spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Join Americans who use data to make smarter decisions. Privacy Policy

Share this page: X Facebook LinkedIn