National Salary Overview
Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks
Median Salary
$51,626
Average (Mean)
$53,098
Employed Nationwide
157,280
VS
Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks
Median Salary
$53,174
Average (Mean)
$57,057
Employed Nationwide
393,980
Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks earns $1,548 more (3.0%)
Key Metrics Compared
Median Salary
$51,626
$53,174
Average (Mean) Salary
$53,098
$57,057
Total Employment
157,280
393,980
States with Higher Pay
18
33
Salary by State: Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks vs Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks
Showing 51 states where both occupations have BLS data. Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks pays more in 18 states; Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks pays more in 33.
| State | Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks | Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks | Difference | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alabama | $40,090 | $52,000 | $-11,910 | ||
| Alaska | $52,620 | $52,890 | $-270 | ||
| Arizona | $46,270 | $52,270 | $-6,000 | ||
| Arkansas | $43,360 | $50,210 | $-6,850 | ||
| California | $60,170 | $60,180 | $-10 | ||
| Colorado | $59,730 | $59,360 | +$370 | ||
| Connecticut | $60,320 | $60,240 | +$80 | ||
| Delaware | $47,950 | $58,260 | $-10,310 | ||
| District of Columbia | $69,730 | $49,270 | +$20,460 | ||
| Florida | $49,060 | $48,820 | +$240 | ||
| Georgia | $52,960 | $50,480 | +$2,480 | ||
| Hawaii | $58,350 | $57,960 | +$390 | ||
| Idaho | $47,060 | $50,140 | $-3,080 | ||
| Illinois | $60,740 | $58,800 | +$1,940 | ||
| Indiana | $48,160 | $55,790 | $-7,630 | ||
| Iowa | $49,780 | $54,500 | $-4,720 | ||
| Kansas | $49,690 | $52,180 | $-2,490 | ||
| Kentucky | $48,810 | $51,590 | $-2,780 | ||
| Louisiana | $46,020 | $54,900 | $-8,880 | ||
| Maine | $50,820 | $52,150 | $-1,330 | ||
| Maryland | $56,060 | $49,080 | +$6,980 | ||
| Massachusetts | $59,230 | $57,920 | +$1,310 | ||
| Michigan | $47,160 | $57,290 | $-10,130 | ||
| Minnesota | $58,050 | $58,500 | $-450 | ||
| Mississippi | $41,420 | $43,490 | $-2,070 | ||
| Missouri | $48,500 | $49,210 | $-710 | ||
| Montana | $44,200 | $47,720 | $-3,520 | ||
| Nebraska | $49,650 | $47,130 | +$2,520 | ||
| Nevada | $51,880 | $53,980 | $-2,100 | ||
| New Hampshire | $55,650 | $59,280 | $-3,630 | ||
| New Jersey | $58,960 | $56,440 | +$2,520 | ||
| New Mexico | $47,840 | $37,700 | +$10,140 | ||
| New York | $58,690 | $57,950 | +$740 | ||
| North Carolina | $49,150 | $49,220 | $-70 | ||
| North Dakota | $54,480 | $57,120 | $-2,640 | ||
| Ohio | $50,060 | $51,580 | $-1,520 | ||
| Oklahoma | $45,220 | $49,180 | $-3,960 | ||
| Oregon | $55,500 | $54,390 | +$1,110 | ||
| Pennsylvania | $50,240 | $50,500 | $-260 | ||
| Rhode Island | $59,690 | $60,900 | $-1,210 | ||
| South Carolina | $47,750 | $50,420 | $-2,670 | ||
| South Dakota | $45,680 | $47,760 | $-2,080 | ||
| Tennessee | $47,470 | $47,420 | +$50 | ||
| Texas | $49,680 | $48,220 | +$1,460 | ||
| Utah | $49,860 | $54,190 | $-4,330 | ||
| Vermont | $54,500 | $50,860 | +$3,640 | ||
| Virginia | $52,210 | $53,160 | $-950 | ||
| Washington | $62,240 | $63,190 | $-950 | ||
| West Virginia | $40,190 | $53,230 | $-13,040 | ||
| Wisconsin | $51,050 | $50,350 | +$700 | ||
| Wyoming | $49,000 | $62,550 | $-13,550 |
Frequently Asked Questions
Who makes more: Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks or Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks?
On average across all states, a Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks earns more than a Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks. The national median salary difference is $1,548 (3.0%) based on 2024 BLS data.
In how many states does a Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks earn more than a Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks?
A Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks earns a higher median salary than a Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks in 18 out of 51 states where both occupations have BLS data. A Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks pays more in 33 states.
What is the median salary for a Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks vs Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks?
The national median salary for a Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks is $51,626 per year, compared to $53,174 for a Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks, according to 2024 BLS OEWS data.
Which has more jobs: Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks or Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks?
There are more people employed as Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks. BLS reports approximately 157,280 Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks positions and 393,980 Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks positions nationwide (2024).
Should I become a Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks or Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks?
Both Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks and Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks are viable career paths. Beyond salary, consider factors like job availability in your state, work-life balance, education requirements, growth potential, and personal interests. Visit each occupation's salary page for state-specific data and career insights.
Explore Career Options
Build a Professional Resume Get Certified & Earn More Learn a New Language Build In-Demand Tech Skills Explore Top Courses Advance Your CareerCompare After-Tax Take-Home Pay
See what each role actually pays after federal, state, and FICA taxes.